Cost – Benefit Analysis Sumatera Large-Scale Marine Protected Area (LSMPA) Network

This report presents the site-based Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) for the proposed Sumatera Large MPA Network, located in Fisheries Management Area (FMA/WPP) 572. It is a site-specific CBA commissioned under Phase 2 of the MMAF, Konservasi Indonesia (KI), Blue Nature Alliance (BNA) LSMPA CBA program, following the national-level assessment completed under Phase 1 (Cost-Benefit Analysis for Achieving Indonesian Marine Protected Areas Vision 30×45). It builds directly on that national analysis by narrowing the lens to FMA 572 and applying the Extended CBA framework set out in the Inception Report, adding distributional analysis, a wider set of ecosystem-service and existence-value benefits, and site-specific financing and zoning recommendations. The analysis compares a Business-As-Usual (BAU) scenario, in which no LSMPA is established and the fishery is managed toward MSY under current arrangements, against three LSMPA establishment scenarios over a 2025–2045 time horizon (21 years, discounted at Indonesia’s social discount rate of 6.82%). All three LSMPA scenarios designate the same 14.74% of FMA 572 (13.74 million of 93.19 million hectares) as a large-scale, multi-use MPA, and differ from one another — and from BAU — only in the fishing-effort/catch policy applied once the MPA is in force. Scenario 1 holds fishing effort at its 2024 level, so catch falls mechanically in proportion to the 14.74% of fishing ground that is closed, with no offsetting stock recovery. Scenario 2 and Scenario 3 instead reduce fishing mortality (F) gradually toward FMSY over 2025–2029 — allowing the stock to rebuild — before raising F again from 2030 onward to 1.05×FMSY (Scenario 2) or 1.10×FMSY (Scenario 3). BAU, for comparison, establishes no MPA with existing effort.